Skip to content
Thursday, November 19, 2026News. Culture. Conversation.
Viralnado
Explore sections
News

‘Oh Boy, Oh Boy’: Trump Judge Pick Stumbles on the 22nd Amendment, Then Won’t Say if Trump Can Run in 2028

Typographic news graphic reading: Trump's judge pick was asked if Trump can run in 2028
Official Senate portrait of Sen. Chris Coons of Delaware, wearing a dark suit, white shirt and blue tie, in front of an American flag and the Delaware state flag

President Trump’s newest pick for a lifetime federal judgeship froze on Wednesday when a Democratic senator asked him to explain the 22nd Amendment, the part of the Constitution that limits presidents to two terms. Then, after the senator read him the opening words, he would not say whether Trump is eligible to run again in 2028.

The nominee, James P. Sullivan, a Texas Supreme Court justice, appeared before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Wednesday, Nov. 18, for his confirmation hearing. Trump has nominated him to be a U.S. district judge for the Western District of Texas.

“Oh boy, oh boy”

Sen. Chris Coons of Delaware began with what he framed as a basic question. “Since we’re just talking about the importance of taking the oath to uphold the Constitution, Mr. Sullivan, can you just tell me what the 22nd Amendment provides?” Coons asked, according to The New Republic and the official hearing video.

“Senator, if I’m remembering correctly, and I carry it over my heart because sometimes it isn’t in my brain, but if I’m remembering it correctly, it is…” Sullivan said, before trailing off: “Oh boy, oh boy.”

Coons offered a hint: “No person shall be elected…”

“Ah yes, I’m sorry, thank you, thank you genuinely, Senator,” Sullivan replied. “No person shall be elected more than twice, I believe, to the office of the president.”

The amendment, ratified in 1951, says: “No person shall be elected to the office of the President more than twice.”

The 2028 question

Coons then asked whether Trump has been elected and served twice. “President Trump has been certified as the winner in the 2016 and the 2024…” Sullivan began.

“Is he eligible to run for president again in 2028?” Coons pressed.

“So, Senator, as a nominee for a federal district court, it would be a violation, I believe, of Canon 5 for me to opine on something like that,” Sullivan said. He added that he was “not so sure” he could answer and that “it certainly seems like it’s the sort of thing that is a subject of ongoing political debate.”

Canon 5 refers to judicial-conduct rules that bar judges and judicial candidates from political activity such as endorsing or opposing candidates.

“That’s a very disappointing answer,” Coons responded. “It strikes me as just bracingly clear on the face of it.”

“I don’t think it is a subject of political debate,” Coons continued. “The question whether someone can serve a third term as president of the United States, I think, is only unresolved in the mind of President Trump.”

Watch the exchange

A Republican senator pushed him too

Coons wasn’t the only one to press Sullivan. Republican Sen. John Kennedy of Louisiana challenged the nominee, a self-described originalist, on the Eighth Amendment’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment, according to Mediaite.

Kennedy noted that when the amendment was adopted, punishments such as cutting off ears were generally accepted, and asked whether Sullivan would support a law allowing it. Sullivan said that as a district judge he would be bound by Supreme Court precedent and that it would not be his place “to grade their homework.”

“You’re talking in circles, Judge,” Kennedy told him. “They either do or they don’t.”

Why this question keeps coming up

Trump has repeatedly floated the idea of a third term. He told NBC News in March 2025 that he was “not joking” about it, and in an April interview with Time he said, “There are some loopholes that have been discussed that are well known.” Coons has asked other Trump judicial nominees about the 22nd Amendment at earlier hearings as well.

Who is James Sullivan?

Sullivan, 45, is a Harvard Law School graduate who clerked on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit and served as an assistant solicitor general in Texas and later as general counsel to Gov. Greg Abbott, who appointed him to the Texas Supreme Court in January 2025, according to The Texas Tribune.

Earlier this month, in his first election, Sullivan lost his seat on the state’s highest civil court to Democrat Chari Kelly as Democrats swept Texas’ statewide offices. A week later, on Nov. 10, Trump announced he was nominating Sullivan to the federal bench, calling him “an incredible jurist and lawyer.” The Senate received the nomination on Nov. 16.

Texas Sen. John Cornyn, a Republican, introduced Sullivan at Wednesday’s hearing and said he looks forward to supporting his confirmation in committee and on the Senate floor.

What happens next

Sullivan’s nomination now awaits a vote in the Judiciary Committee before it can go to the full Senate. Republicans are racing to confirm judicial nominees before Democrats take control of the Senate in January, The Texas Tribune reported, which means the clock is ticking on his nomination.

Viralnado will update this story as the nomination moves forward.

Reporting draws on The New Republic, The Texas Tribune, Mediaite and the official Senate Judiciary Committee hearing video.