
Sen. John Cornyn of Texas is blocking one of President Donald Trump’s final picks for a lifetime federal judgeship, and the fight has split Texas’ two Republican senators so badly that it spilled into a shouting match on the Senate floor.
Cornyn told The Associated Press on Wednesday, Nov. 18, that he has not returned his “blue slip” for T. Elliot Gaiser, Trump’s nominee for the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas, the Dallas-area federal bench, and that he does not plan to.
“He’s not from Texas. He hasn’t been vetted. And this is a lifetime job, and there’s better qualified people to hold that job,” Cornyn told the AP.
“I don’t find you credible”
The dispute boiled over on the Senate floor on Tuesday, Nov. 17. According to The Washington Sun, whose reporters heard the exchange from the press gallery above the mostly empty chamber, Cornyn was yelling at Sen. Ted Cruz, his fellow Texas Republican and Gaiser’s chief backer.
“I don’t find you credible. I’m mad at you!” Cornyn told Cruz, according to The Sun. Cornyn also said he was upset at someone “for ending my career!” The Sun said it could not tell whether that remark was aimed at Cruz or at Trump, who endorsed Ken Paxton against Cornyn in this year’s Texas Republican Senate primary.
After a reply from Cruz that reporters could not hear, Cornyn shot back, “Oh, that’s bulls—!” and then waved Cruz off and stormed away toward the Democratic side of the aisle, The Sun reported.
Afterward, Cornyn told The Sun that Cruz is “not happy that the White House has made it impossible for me to support their nominee Elliot Gaiser.” Asked why Cornyn was so upset, Cruz said, “You’d have to ask him,” and declined to comment further.
Why Cornyn says no
Cornyn told CBS News that Gaiser’s nomination is “no longer viable.”
“He’s not a Texan, has no trial experience, and the White House tried to jam the Senate and wouldn’t allow us to do our due diligence that we need to do on lifetime appointments,” he said.
He also told the AP that “it’s hard to provide advice and consent when there’s zero consultation, which happened in that case.” Cornyn has noted that Gaiser was never vetted by the bipartisan federal judicial evaluation committee traditionally used in Texas.
“I just refuse to be jammed by a non-Texan who has no trial experience, who hasn’t been vetted,” Cornyn told CNN, according to The Hill. “And so, we provided the White House an alternative, and I’m hoping they take advantage of it because I don’t want the seat to go vacant either.”
Who is Elliot Gaiser?
Gaiser leads the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel, which issues legal opinions that bind the executive branch. He is an Ohio native and a former Ohio solicitor general, and a former Supreme Court clerk. His main tie to Texas appears to be a one-year clerkship in Houston for Judge Edith Jones of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit, according to CBS News and Bloomberg Law.
According to his questionnaire to the Senate Judiciary Committee, Gaiser was first contacted about the judgeship by Cruz’s staff on Nov. 4, the day after the midterm elections. Trump announced the nomination last week, and it was formally sent to the Senate on Monday, Nov. 16. Gaiser had been expected to appear at Wednesday’s Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing but was left off the agenda.
At the Justice Department, Gaiser wrote the opinion justifying U.S. military strikes on alleged drug-smuggling boats, an April opinion calling the Presidential Records Act unconstitutional, and an August opinion finding that Trump’s communications with outside advisers are generally covered by executive privilege, CBS News reported.
Cornyn was gentler on Gaiser personally. “He’s a very bright young man, and I think has a very bright future,” he told the AP. “I kind of feel bad that he’s been used basically as a pawn in this process.”
Cornyn’s alternative
Cornyn is pushing the White House to nominate Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey instead. Fahey served in the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Northern District of Texas from 2003 until 2021 and was a partner at Kirkland & Ellis before starting his own firm in 2024, according to the AP. Cornyn said the White House has requested information about Fahey, and that he did not know whether Gaiser would be formally withdrawn.
Cruz: Democrats would get the seat
Cruz says Gaiser is the only realistic option. In a statement Wednesday, he called Gaiser “exceptionally well qualified” and the “only nominee who could actually be confirmed by the end of the year,” arguing that a brand-new nominee could not clear an FBI background check in time.
“If the Senate Judiciary Committee does not move Gaiser forward, the people of Texas will pay the price because it will effectively give the judicial seat to the Democrats, who will keep it vacant in perpetuity,” Cruz said. “That would be a tragedy.”
A White House official told the AP the administration expects all of Trump’s judicial nominees to be confirmed by the end of the year.
What a blue slip is, and why the clock matters
Under a longstanding Senate Judiciary Committee custom, district court nominees advance only if both home-state senators return positive blue slips. Trump has pushed committee Chairman Chuck Grassley to scrap the practice, but Grassley has kept it in place for district court and U.S. attorney nominees.
The timing is what makes this fight so intense. Democrats won control of the Senate in the Nov. 3 midterms and take over in January, and Republicans are racing to confirm as many of Trump’s judges as possible during the lame-duck session. Cornyn, who lost the Texas GOP primary to Paxton, is leaving the Senate. Paxton went on to lose the general election to Democrat James Talarico, who will take Cornyn’s seat and inherit the same blue-slip power over Texas district court picks.
The two Texans already had a strained relationship. The Washington Sun noted that Cruz stayed neutral in Cornyn’s primary while his political firm, Axiom Strategies, worked for Paxton. “I just knew he was never one of my supporters,” Cornyn told The Sun.
Viralnado will update this story if the White House withdraws Gaiser or nominates a replacement.
Reporting draws on The Associated Press, CBS News, The Washington Sun, The Hill, CNN, Bloomberg Law and the Washington Examiner.
