
The Department of Homeland Security went too far when it loosened training requirements for the thousands of Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers hired to power President Donald Trump’s mass deportation campaign, according to a draft report from the department’s own internal watchdog.
The 19-page draft from the DHS Office of Inspector General, obtained by The New York Times, has not been finalized or released. The Times described it as a sweeping critique of the plan carried out under former Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem to rapidly hire and deploy 10,000 new ICE officers, paid for with tens of billions of dollars approved by Congress.
One recruit instructor quoted in the draft called the rollback of training standards a “catastrophic failure.”
Basic training, online, in hours
Before the hiring surge, basic training was done fully in person at a training center over the course of about a month. According to the draft, more than 3,500 recruits who had previous law enforcement experience were instead allowed to complete their basic training online. That group makes up roughly 35% of ICE’s active deportation officers nationwide, the Times reported.
The online option let recruits speed through the material:
- More than 80% of those recruits finished the online coursework within 10 days.
- More than 10% finished in less than 24 hours.
- At least five got through the material in just two hours.
Unlimited retakes, and one officer who needed 32 tries
The draft also faulted DHS for scrapping a rule that gave recruits only two chances to pass a training test. As the department raced to expand its ranks, recruits were allowed to retake the test as many times as needed. One officer took it 32 times before passing.
In all, nearly 6,000 officers went through a sharply reduced training model between August 2025 and roughly July 2026, according to the draft. That includes more than 2,000 recruits with no prior law enforcement experience, whose instruction was cut from 543 hours to roughly 300. The reductions reached firearms instruction, arrest procedures, driving techniques and other core law enforcement skills.
Another instructor warned that poorly prepared recruits could become liabilities. The department tried to make up for the cuts with on-the-job training, but nearly 90% of the ICE officials overseeing that program who answered the watchdog’s questionnaire said it was “not successful.”
Who pushed it
According to the draft, the changes were strongly supported by Noem and her senior adviser, Corey Lewandowski. ICE’s former training chief told investigators he had been ordered to carry out the reductions. Noem was ousted by Trump in March. Representatives for Noem did not respond to requests for comment.
The fixes came later, and the gaps remain
Current Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin restored stricter training standards in July, the draft noted. But the watchdog warned that the problem has not gone away for the officers who were already hired:
Despite increasing training hours and days for future recruits, ICE has not fully addressed training gaps born of the reductions and revisions.
Draft DHS Office of Inspector General report
Asked about the changes at a congressional hearing this week, Mullin acknowledged: “There were some decisions that were made before I was secretary that we are having to undo.”
The draft did not examine whether the weaker training contributed to violent encounters on the street. But at least one officer involved in a recent fatal incident joined ICE while the lower standards were in place: David Brouillette, hired in December 2025, fatally shot Johan Sebastián Durán Guerrero, a 25-year-old Colombian immigrant, during a vehicle stop in Maine this summer.
What DHS and the watchdog say
DHS said Mullin moved quickly after taking over and that officers are receiving additional training. An ICE spokesperson told the Times that “a significant portion of officers brought on during the hiring surge have law enforcement experience and have already successfully completed a law enforcement academy.”
DHS Inspector General Joseph V. Cuffari objected to the leak. His office strongly condemned “the premature release of draft reports before the department has had the opportunity to complete its review and provide formal comments,” he told the Times, adding that such disclosures “undermine the integrity of the oversight process.”
Not the first warning
The findings echo a warning from February, when former ICE instructor Ryan Schwank came forward as a whistleblower at a forum held by congressional Democrats and described the agency’s training program as “deficient, defective and broken.” At the time, DHS denied that any requirements had been eliminated.
The report lands as Democrats prepare to take control of both chambers of Congress in January. Separately on Friday, Sen. Bernie Sanders called on the incoming Democratic majority to act on ICE’s funding:
ICE agents have shot Americans, broken down doors and sent 5-year-old children to detention centers. These actions are immoral and unconstitutional. Democrats must rescind the $75 billion Republicans gave ICE and enact immigration reform with a path to citizenship.
Sen. Bernie Sanders, on X
The inspector general’s findings could still change before the final report is released. Viralnado will update this story as more details emerge.
This report draws on reporting by The New York Times, which obtained the draft inspector general report, with additional details reported by Mediaite and The Daily Beast.
