Skip to content
Friday, November 20, 2026News. Culture. Conversation.
Viralnado
Explore sections
News

Trump DOJ Appointees Pushed a $500,000 IRS Payout to a Trump Golf Pro, 250 Times What the Law Calls For

Breaking news graphic with a stack of cash bundles beside a golf hole and red flag, headline: Trump's golf pro got a $500K IRS payout

Top Trump administration officials intervened to help a longtime golf pro at Trump National Golf Club Hudson Valley secure a half-million-dollar payout from the IRS, ProPublica reported Thursday. A company connected to President Donald Trump’s media business also got a half-million.

The limestone facade of the Internal Revenue Service Building in Washington, D.C., with three tall arched entrance doors behind a row of potted plants

The money came out of a little-noticed federal class-action lawsuit filed in 2025 by five individuals and companies who accused the IRS of failing to protect their tax information. Together, the group got $2.5 million. According to ProPublica, the deal was made without the IRS’s agreement, and it alarmed agency officials.

250 times what the law calls for

The law permits a $1,000 payment to victims for each instance of an unauthorized inspection or disclosure of tax data. The plaintiffs alleged two unauthorized disclosures of their tax information, which would entitle each of them to $2,000 under the statute. To get more, they would have to prove actual damages.

But before the case reached the fact-finding stage, the Justice Department stopped fighting it. In August, the department made a unilateral proposal to the five named plaintiffs, labeled an offer of judgment, to pay them $500,000 each, court records show. ProPublica reported that the settlement is 250 times higher than what the law calls for given the allegations. Multiple officials told the outlet that such cases almost never result in payments approaching that size.

When IRS employees learned about the $2.5 million offer, they pointed out that it was dramatically higher than what the law called for and was not supported by any evidence, according to people familiar with the case and documents seen by ProPublica. IRS Office of Chief Counsel attorneys were also not consulted about the settlement terms, which is standard practice, the outlet reported.

Signed by two political appointees

Who made the offer also stood out. The career DOJ trial attorney working the case did not sign the proposed payout, as is typical. Instead, according to ProPublica, it was delivered by two Trump political appointees: Brett Shumate, then head of the Justice Department’s Civil Division, and Joshua Wu, the deputy assistant attorney general for the department’s tax litigation branch. Shumate left the DOJ in early November and did not respond to requests for comment.

Earlier in the case, the Justice Department had tried to get the lawsuit dismissed, with a DOJ trial attorney arguing among other things that the U.S. government was not the proper target for a suit about a contractor’s conduct. The judge rejected that motion and cleared the way for discovery and potentially a trial.

The tax leak behind the lawsuit

The case is Safe Harbor International LLC v. Booz Allen Hamilton, Internal Revenue Service and the U.S. Department of the Treasury, filed in federal court in Maryland. The plaintiffs claim the IRS and contractor Booz Allen failed to put proper safeguards in place and were negligent in allowing Booz Allen employee Charles Littlejohn to steal tax records and give them to news organizations.

Littlejohn has said he leaked confidential IRS data to ProPublica and The New York Times between 2018 and 2020, including years of Trump’s taxes. He pleaded guilty in October 2023 to unauthorized disclosure of tax information and was sentenced to five years in prison. The IRS later sent letters to more than 400,000 individuals and businesses telling them their taxpayer information had been “inappropriately disclosed.”

Who got paid

The five plaintiffs were Safe Harbor International, an obscure Delaware LLC; Texas-based Alarm Concepts; a Connecticut company called Belpointe Sleepovation Investment; a Texas man named Cedrick Williams; and Shelby Lowman, the golf pro at Trump National Golf Club Hudson Valley.

Lowman has worked at the club for about 17 years, according to his LinkedIn profile, starting before Trump bought it in 2009. He also paints scenes of Trump’s golf properties, and Trump has autographed copies of his paintings to be given out as prizes at club competitions, ProPublica reported. It is unclear whether Trump knows Lowman personally.

Safe Harbor has no website or public presence, ProPublica found. Its investors include Donald Wilson, who leads a Chicago-based trading firm. The Securities and Exchange Commission dropped a case against a crypto company Wilson controlled last March, and a few months later his firm said it had invested $100 million in Trump Media and Technology Group, the owner of Truth Social. A spokesperson for Wilson said he is a passive shareholder in Safe Harbor who “was unaware of this lawsuit until last week and has had no involvement in the litigation or any settlement discussions,” adding: “There was no quid pro quo, and the investment was not made in exchange for any regulatory action.”

A Trump Organization spokesperson said the company “had no involvement in or connection to this lawsuit. To the extent any current or former employees are involved, it is entirely in their personal capacity as individual taxpayers.” Lowman, Williams and Alarm Concepts did not respond to ProPublica’s requests for comment. A lawyer for Belpointe said it was “news to me” that other plaintiffs had “ties to the Trump administration.”

“Not passing the smell test”

Gil Rothenberg, an American University law professor who ran the appellate section of the Justice Department’s tax division for 15 years before leaving in 2019, told ProPublica the deal “is not passing the smell test.”

“It’s not just the amount that I find odd and unusual. It’s the fact that this settlement amount occurred before any final decision by the district court, and basically the DOJ is giving up any right to appeal.”

In 2022, billionaire investor Ken Griffin brought a similar suit against the IRS. He dropped it a year and a half later after receiving an apology and a pledge to improve data security, and he received no money, ProPublica noted.

The case isn’t over

The payouts did not end the lawsuit. After the settlement, two more people came forward seeking to continue the litigation, and both are connected to Trump businesses, according to ProPublica: a retired accountant who worked at the same Trump property as Lowman, and a person who appears to be a former lifeguard at a different Trump golf club in Westchester County, New York.

The plaintiffs claim the size of the class is “in the tens or hundreds of thousands.” If a significant number of them secured the same payment, the federal government’s total liability could reach into the billions of dollars. A judge has yet to rule on whether to allow the case to proceed. Former IRS Commissioner John Koskinen, who led the agency from 2013 to 2017, said the deal even “opens the door to Trump himself benefiting from this settlement.”

Critics fear the payment could be a backdoor way to revive something like the $1.776 billion “anti-weaponization fund” the Justice Department announced earlier this year to resolve Trump’s own $10 billion lawsuit over similar claims. That fund drew public outrage and objections from Democratic and some Republican lawmakers before the department dropped the idea.

What the administration says

Spokespeople for the Justice Department and the IRS said they would not comment on a pending case. A White House spokesperson said the Justice Department is “promoting efficient resolution of cases to avoid extraordinary liability.”

Whether the court lets the case move forward, and whether more people connected to Trump businesses seek similar payouts, are the next things to watch.