
Sen. Elissa Slotkin is done playing defense. The Michigan Democrat has sent a blistering letter to the Trump-appointed federal prosecutor who threatened to investigate her over comments about congressional oversight, calling his inquiry “baseless,” a “sham investigation” and a “violation of your ethical duties as an attorney” — and demanding that he withdraw his letter immediately.
The target of her response is Aaron Reitz, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of Texas. Last week, Reitz posted a letter addressed to Slotkin on social media suggesting that her remarks about holding Trump administration officials accountable could amount to a criminal civil rights offense, NBC News reported.
What Reitz claimed
Reitz’s letter focused on comments Slotkin made on a podcast recorded at the University of Chicago in October. According to Reitz, Slotkin said that if Democrats take the Senate majority, she wanted congressional investigations to send a “deterrence message” to people who associate with President Donald Trump, FOX 2 Detroit reported.
The letter cites two federal civil rights statutes and demands that Slotkin preserve her records, according to The Washington Times. Notices like that can come before a formal investigation.
Slotkin says her point was far simpler: that “if you violate the law or abuse taxpayer dollars, you should be held accountable.”
‘Your threat of investigation is baseless’
In her letter, sent Wednesday and obtained by NBC News, Slotkin argued that both the First Amendment and the Constitution itself protect what she said.
“I made those statements consistent with my basic right to freedom of speech, a right that every American enjoys under the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution,” she wrote. “In addition to my First Amendment rights, as a United States Senator, oversight is an important constitutional responsibility.”
“The Constitution’s Speech or Debate clause bars prosecution of a legislator for conducting an investigation or performing other legislative acts,” she continued. “As such, your threat of investigation is baseless, and you should withdraw your letter immediately.”
Slotkin also accused Reitz of violating Justice Department policy with his “public threats.” She said his decision to post the letter publicly, instead of sending it to her, her attorney or the Senate legal counsel, “is evidence that your threat of investigation is more about publicity and your political ambitions than any sort of legitimate inquiry.”
“Given all of this, your threats are frivolous and a violation of your ethical duties as an attorney,” she wrote. “I reserve all rights to take appropriate actions in the future as it relates to this sham investigation.”
‘Come get me’
Slotkin went further in a video she posted to X on Wednesday night.
“A week ago, I got a letter from the Department of Justice, specifically from the U.S. Attorney of the Southern District of Texas, of all places, threatening a criminal investigation of me because I said aloud in a podcast that if you violate the law or waste taxpayer dollars, you should be held accountable,” she said.
“Today I sent a letter back. I responded to that threatening letter. I’m not going to participate in some sham investigation,” Slotkin said. “Every American has freedom of speech.”
She called the effort part of a long-term strategy to “use the Department of Justice to come after their political adversaries,” adding: “It’s a well-worn authoritarian playbook, something we’ve seen in other countries many, many times.”
“The bottom line is it does not deter me. It doesn’t scare me away,” she said. Then she laid down a challenge: “If there’s a legal case to be made that you should prosecute someone for freedom of speech, do it. Come get me, right? This is something that is fundamental to who we are as Americans. Every American child understands freedom of speech.”
Not the first time
This is the second time this year the Trump administration has come after Slotkin over her words. Earlier this year, she and five other Democratic lawmakers were targeted over a video reminding members of the military and intelligence community that they should not obey unlawful orders. Allies of Washington, D.C., U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro tried to indict the six Democrats over that video, but federal grand jurors unanimously rejected the indictment attempt, according to NBC News.
Trump said on Oct. 20 that Slotkin “should be tried” over her podcast remarks, and he later publicly called on the Justice Department to look into her speech, which he dubbed a “criminal act.” Slotkin’s attorney, former federal prosecutor Preet Bharara, previously wrote to Attorney General Todd Blanche cautioning him against following that instruction.
Blanche himself has conceded that Slotkin’s words alone were “absolutely not a crime.” At a news conference last week, he said there were “no ongoing investigations, criminal investigations, into words that incoming senators or congressmen have said,” NBC News reported.
Who is Aaron Reitz?
Reitz, 39, is a former chief of staff to Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas. He became U.S. attorney for the Southern District of Texas over the summer after finishing fourth in the Republican primary for Texas attorney general, according to NBC News.
Slotkin is one of five Democratic members of Congress who have been the subject of letters Reitz has posted on X. The others are Sens. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts, Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut and Adam Schiff of California, along with Rep. Robert Garcia of California, who is poised to lead the House Oversight Committee. Legal experts have scrutinized the letters, and Reitz told NBC News this week that he was “not interested in chilling free speech.”
What happens next
Reitz has not withdrawn the letter, and the fight is far from over. Slotkin and other senators were scheduled to speak at a news conference Thursday afternoon marking one year since they posted their video about refusing illegal orders, FOX 2 Detroit reported.
For now, Slotkin’s message to the prosecutor is clear: she will not take part in what she calls a “sham investigation” — and if he thinks he has a case, she says, he should try to make it.
