
A federal judge appointed by Ronald Reagan has struck down the Trump administration’s restrictions on a lifesaving federal HIV program, ruling that rules targeting transgender patients were unconstitutional, and closing his decision with some of the bluntest language yet aimed at the administration’s anti-trans agenda.
“They are based in animus, loathing, and discrimination,” U.S. District Judge William G. Young wrote of the funding conditions. “They do not stand for justice — in fact, they defy it. They are contrary to the laws of this nation and cannot continue to stand.”
What the judge ruled
In a 165-page decision issued Thursday, Nov. 19, in federal court in Boston, Young ruled that the administration cannot bar health care providers who receive money from the Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program from acknowledging the gender identity of their transgender patients or from providing them gender-affirming care, Reuters reported.
Young found that the conditions were designed to suppress what the administration considered “dangerous ideas,” violating the First Amendment by penalizing doctors for acknowledging that transgender people exist and for referring to patients by their pronouns. He also found the rules amounted to unconstitutional sex discrimination under the Fifth Amendment.
The judge declared the conditions unlawful and vacated them, according to Lambda Legal, which brought the case. He also permanently blocked the administration from imposing the conditions, or any similar policies, on members of the medical groups that sued. Lambda Legal says that covers virtually every HIV care provider in the United States.
The rules Trump’s team imposed
The Ryan White program was created by Congress in 1990 to provide medical care for low-income and uninsured people living with HIV. According to Lambda Legal, about 60% of people living with HIV in America get services through it.
After President Trump signed an executive order directing the federal government to recognize only two sexes and barring federal funding for what he calls “gender ideology,” the Health Resources and Services Administration, the division of the Department of Health and Human Services that runs the program, added new conditions to Ryan White grants. Providers were required to ensure the money supported activities using “sex-based definitions grounded in biological reality” and not “social or medical experimentation,” according to the lawsuit.
In practice, the medical groups said, providers who took the money could not acknowledge or respect their transgender patients’ identities or use program funds for gender-affirming medical care, even though the program has historically covered hormone therapy for transgender people as part of comprehensive HIV care.
“A dark departure”
Young, a Reagan appointee, ended his ruling with a passage about the country itself:
“The United States is a fundamentally good nation with a fundamentally good people. It is generous, compassionate, and wonderfully diverse. It is accepting of all, and its people recognize a common heritage. It is not without problems, but is nevertheless exceptional. The Challenged Conditions here represent a dark departure from these truths. They are based in animus, loathing, and discrimination. They do not stand for justice — in fact, they defy it. They are contrary to the laws of this nation and cannot continue to stand.”
U.S. District Judge William G. Young
Who sued, and what they’re saying
The lawsuit was filed in June by Lambda Legal and the law firm Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer on behalf of the American Academy of HIV Medicine, the HIV Medicine Association, the International Association of Providers of AIDS Care and individual providers. Young ruled after a non-jury trial held Sept. 23.
Jose Abrigo, HIV Project director at Lambda Legal, called the decision “a sweeping victory for the doctors, nurses, and patients who rely on the Ryan White Program across the country.” “Congress built this program to follow a patient’s medical need, and the administration cannot override that by attaching discriminatory conditions to a grant,” he said. “For transgender people living with HIV, being treated by a provider who respects them is what keeps them coming back for treatment.”
Bruce Packett, executive director of the American Academy of HIV Medicine, said nearly half of the group’s members rely on Ryan White funding, and almost half of those provide gender-affirming care. “Now, these clinicians no longer have to choose between federal compliance and their duty of care to their patients,” he said.
Atlanta HIV physician Dr. Melanie Thompson, a past chair of the HIV Medicine Association, said comprehensive care including gender-affirming care is strongly tied to patients staying in treatment and achieving viral suppression, which “protects patients and prevents transmission to others.”
What happens next
HHS did not immediately respond to a request for comment, Reuters reported. The administration can appeal the ruling.
The HIV funding fight is part of a broader Trump crackdown on transgender rights. The administration has banned transgender people from the military and barred passport applicants from choosing a gender marker matching their identity, moves the Supreme Court allowed to take effect. It has also moved to restrict gender-affirming care for transgender people in federal prisons and backed state bans on transgender athletes in girls’ and women’s sports.
Viralnado will update this story if the administration appeals.
Sources: Reuters, Bloomberg Law, The Guardian, Lambda Legal and the American Academy of HIV Medicine.
